The Berkeley Kitchen Forum
Should Berkeley City Council Affirm that Free Speech & Assembly rights apply to U.S. Military Recruiters?
Changes from Version 3
Deadline extended
Question
Should Berkeley City Council Affirm that Free Speech & Assembly rights apply to U.S. Military Recruiters?
Summary
Arguments have been made about the right of the USMC Officer Selection Office to continue to exist. Even some Council members have spoken against the appropriateness of the Office remaining open -- in a town like Berkeley.
To shut down this Office nullifies any Berkeley claim to support for tolerance and Free Speech. Free Speech must include speech with which one disagrees; tolerance applies only when there are possible differences of opinion or choice.
Should Council Members support the right of this Office to exist in Berkeley?
Article
The issue of support for the presence of a USMC Officer Selection Office in Berkeley pits Berkeley’s traditional anti-war stance against its historic commitment to free speech and assembly.
Citizens, and some City Council members, have spoken out against the location of a Marine Officer Selection Office in Berkeley -- a city that officially opposes the current conflict in Iraq. There is a desire to protect our youth from contact with recruiters and a concern about the actions of dishonest recruiters in other parts of the country.
As traditional as is Berkeley’s anti-war philosophy, the city has an equally long and passionate history of support for the rights of free speech and assembly, which supports the right of this Office to exist in Berkeley. The essence of the Free Speech Movement was protecting the right of all voices to be heard, even those at odds with the prevailing political climate of the time and place.
Free Speech must not be limited to speech with which one agrees. To allow a legally permitted Office to be shut down, or to limit its right to do business because one disapproves of its message, gives lie to Berkeley’s claim as a city tolerant of diverse viewpoints, and home of the Free Speech Movement.
No one can limit the right of individuals to ignore a recruiting office, but a city must not take the position of opposing the existence of that Office. It is appropriate that the City Council of Berkeley affirm the right of this office to exist and allow it to succeed or fail on its own merits.
Should Council Members support the right of this Office to exist in Berkeley
Citizens, and some City Council members, have spoken out against the location of a Marine Officer Selection Office in Berkeley -- a city that officially opposes the current conflict in Iraq. There is a desire to protect our youth from contact with recruiters and a concern about the actions of dishonest recruiters in other parts of the country.
As traditional as is Berkeley’s anti-war philosophy, the city has an equally long and passionate history of support for the rights of free speech and assembly, which supports the right of this Office to exist in Berkeley. The essence of the Free Speech Movement was protecting the right of all voices to be heard, even those at odds with the prevailing political climate of the time and place.
Free Speech must not be limited to speech with which one agrees. To allow a legally permitted Office to be shut down, or to limit its right to do business because one disapproves of its message, gives lie to Berkeley’s claim as a city tolerant of diverse viewpoints, and home of the Free Speech Movement.
No one can limit the right of individuals to ignore a recruiting office, but a city must not take the position of opposing the existence of that Office. It is appropriate that the City Council of Berkeley affirm the right of this office to exist and allow it to succeed or fail on its own merits.
Should Council Members support the right of this Office to exist in Berkeley
Deadline
2008-09-15 22:00:00 -0700
Version 4 committed April 19, 2008, 1:02 PM
